Showing posts with label CONAIE. Show all posts
Showing posts with label CONAIE. Show all posts

Friday, October 21, 2022

Why doesn't the Ecuador country risk go down?

By Luis Fierro Carrion (*)

Twitter: @Luis_Fierro_C

In recent weeks, the so-called "country risk" of Ecuador, instead of going down, has continued to rise, reaching 1,945 basis points (that is, 19.45% above the US Treasury bond rate). .

The "country risk" essentially reflects the probability that a country declares a default on servicing its foreign debt. It is true that Ecuador has a negative trajectory in this regard, having declared a moratorium on 11 occasions, tying with Venezuela and Argentina in the moratorium record (the last in 2020, at the beginning of the pandemic). (Spain has more defaults, but over 5 centuries).

However, Ecuador's macroeconomic indicators should rather have induced a reduction in said risk differential.

A few weeks ago, an agreement was announced to restructure the external debt with Chinese entities, reducing the interest rate between 0.2 and 1%; extending deadlines; and reducing debt service by $870 million in 2022-23.

The fiscal deficit has fallen from $7.1 billion in 2020 to $2.3 billion in 2022. The public debt/GDP ratio will drop from 62.2% of GDP in 2020 to 57% of GDP in 2023. International reserves have exceeded $8.4 billion (having fallen to less than $2 billion in March 2020). The average price of oil has exceeded IMF projections (by $24.20 per barrel in 2022, and by $13.50 per barrel in the medium term). The projected GDP growth rate in 2022 (2.9% according to the IMF) is one of the highest in the region, while inflation is one of the lowest (4.1%).

All these objective macroeconomic factors should have lowered the country risk to around 500-600 points, but instead it has shot up to almost 2,000 points.

The explanation, therefore, is not that the default risk has increased in the short term (I would say that this risk is zero, given that the main payments to the IMF and China have been postponed from 2025, and of sovereign bonds to 2026).

The concern is fundamentally political:

  • It is considered that the government of President Lasso will not be able to approve structural reforms in the Assembly, for example, in the labor or investment legislation.
  • The commitment to double oil production does not seem viable (mining production will continue to increase, but gradually).
  • There is a risk that the Assembly will dismiss the President, or that he will invoke the "simultaneous death" (closing the Assembly and calling for new elections).
  • Although the leader of the indigenous confederation, Leonidas Iza, has weakened his support within the indigenous movement, a new “national insurrection” is still possible, affecting oil, mining, and rural production (agriculture, livestock, flowers, etc.).
  • It is feared that the next government (either a product of the “crossed death”, or regular elections in 2025) will not be “market friendly” and will invoke a new debt moratorium.

The "Iza effect" then becomes in reality an Iza-Correa-PSC-Pachakutik effect. Some PSC spokespersons (among them Mayor Cynthia Viteri) have questioned the servicing of the external debt, and apparently they have a close alliance with Correísmo and the “anti-capitalist” sectors of the Pachakutik movement.

There are also technical factors that affect Ecuador's country risk, such as low liquidity and high transaction costs, given that the country is not a recurring issuer.

In the long term, the only way to overcome this perception of high risk is by achieving a fiscal agreement between the main political forces, assuming as an objective to lower the cost of the country's external financing; and tax reforms that raise the level of fiscal pressure in the country to levels close to the average for Latin America. Currently, it is 19.1% of GDP, while the average for Latin America is 21.9%, and for OECD countries 33.5%.


(*) Translated version of the column published in "El Universo" newspaper on October 20, 2022

https://www.eluniverso.com/opinion/columnistas/por-que-no-baja-el-riesgo-pais-nota/




¿Por qué no baja el riesgo país?

 Por Luis Fierro Carrión (*)

Twitter: @Luis_Fierro_C

En las últimas semanas, el llamado “riesgo país” del Ecuador, en lugar de bajar, ha seguido subiendo, alcanzando 1.945 puntos básicos (esto es, 19,45 % por encima de la tasa de los bonos del Tesoro de EE.UU.).

El “riesgo país” en esencia refleja la probabilidad de que un país declare la moratoria en el servicio de su deuda externa. Es cierto que el Ecuador tiene una trayectoria negativa en este sentido, habiendo declarado moratoria en 11 ocasiones, empatando con Venezuela y Argentina en el récord de moratorias (la última en 2020, al inicio de la pandemia). (España tiene más moratorias, pero a lo largo de 5 siglos).

No obstante, los indicadores macroeconómicos del Ecuador mas bien deberían haber inducido una reducción de dicho diferencial.

Hace unas semanas se anunció un acuerdo para reestructurar la deuda externa con entidades chinas, reduciendo la tasa de interés entre 0,2 y 1 %; extendiendo los plazos; y reduciendo el servicio de la deuda en $870 millones en 2022-23.

El déficit fiscal ha bajado de $7.100 millones en 2020 a $2.300 millones en 2022. La relación deuda pública/PIB bajará de 62,2 % del PIB en 2020, a 57 % del PIB en 2023. Las reservas internacionales han superado $8.400 millones (habiendo bajado a menos de $2.000 millones en marzo 2020).  El precio promedio del petróleo ha superado las proyecciones del FMI (por $24,20 por barril en 2022, y en $13,50 por barril en un plazo mediano). La tasa de crecimiento del PIB prevista en 2022 (2,9 % según el FMI) es una de las mas altas en la región, en tanto que la inflación es una de las más bajas (4,1 %).

Todos estos factores macroeconómicos objetivos deberían haber bajado el riesgo país a unos 500-600 puntos, pero en su lugar se ha disparado a cerca de 2.000 puntos.

La explicación, por ende, no es que haya aumentado el riesgo de moratoria en el corto plazo (diría que ese riesgo es cero, dado que los pagos principales del FMI y China se han postergado a partir de 2025, y de los bonos soberanos a 2026).

La preocupación es fundamentalmente política:

  •       Se considera que el gobierno del Presidente Lasso no podrá aprobar reformas estructurales en la Asamblea, por ejemplo, en el ámbito laboral o de inversiones.
  •       No parece viable la apuesta por duplicar la producción petrolera (la producción minera seguirá aumentando, pero gradualmente).
  •       Existe un riesgo de que la Asamblea destituya al Presidente, o que este invoque la “muerte cruzada”.
  •       Si bien el Sr. Iza se ha debilitado al interior del movimiento indígena, todavía es posible un nuevo “estallido” que afecte la producción petrolera, minera y rural (agrícola, ganadera, florícola, etc.).
  •       Se teme que el próximo gobierno (sea producto de la “muerte cruzada”, o de elecciones regulares en 2025) no sea “amigable al mercado” e invoque una nueva moratoria de la deuda.

El “efecto Iza” entonces se vuelve en realidad en un efecto Iza-Correa-PSC-Pachakutik. Algunos voceros del PSC (entre ellos la Alcaldesa Viteri) han cuestionado el servicio de la deuda externa, y al parecer tienen una alianza estrecha con el Correísmo y los sectores “anticapitalistas” del movimiento Pachakutik.

También hay factores técnicos que afectan el riesgo país de Ecuador, tal como la escasa liquidez y elevado costo de transacción, dado que el país no es un emisor recurrente.

A largo plazo, la única forma de superar esta percepción de elevado riesgo es logrando un acuerdo fiscal entre las principales fuerzas políticas, asumiendo como un objetivo rebajar el costo del financiamiento externo del país; y reformas tributarias que eleven el nivel de presión fiscal del país a niveles cercanos al promedio de América Latina.  Actualmente, es del 19,1 % del PIB, mientras que el promedio de América Latina es 21,9 %, y para los países de la OCDE 33,5 %.


(*) Una versión más corta de esta columna se publicó en el Diario "El Universo" del Ecuador el 20 de octubre de 2022

https://www.eluniverso.com/opinion/columnistas/por-que-no-baja-el-riesgo-pais-nota/

 




Friday, July 15, 2022

Indoamerican communism is barbarism

By Luis Fierro Carrion (*)

Twitter: @Luis_Fierro_C

The president of CONAIE, Leonidas Iza, and his co-authors (Andrés Madrid, Secretary of the Casa de la Cultura; and Andrés Tapia, communication director for CONFENIAE), conclude their book “Estallido” (Outbreak) with the phrase “The light at the end of the tunnel comes from the believed, searched and urgent affirmation: Indoamerican Communism or barbarism”.

The three of them, together with Andrés Madrid's father, Dimitri Madrid (Dean of the Faculty of Social Communication of the Central University of Ecuador) have been the visible leaders of the mariateguista movement in Ecuador.

This movement takes its name from the Peruvian Marxist José Carlos Mariátegui, who founded the Peruvian Socialist Party in 1928, which, after his death in 1930, would become the Peruvian Communist Party, aligned with Stalinism and the Comintern.

Nevertheless, Mariátegui was an original Marxist philosopher, emphasizing the role of the indigenous masses as the authentic “proletariat” of the continent and proclaiming the need for a socialist revolution. In some way, he was ahead of Maoism, a Marxist current that also gave an important role to the peasantry (after the Japanese invasion of China, Mao launched the "Yan'an Rectification Movement" in 1942, which carried out the main deviation from the Soviet line, highlighting the importance of the peasantry as a revolutionary subject).

Other Marxist leaders who continued in this line were Pol Pot in Cambodia, and Abimael Guzmán, leader of Sendero Luminoso in Peru (the very name of his terrorist group derives from a phrase by Mariátegui: "Marxism-Leninism is the shining path of the future").

In the book "Estallido", Marxist thinkers such as Lenin, Rosa Luxemburg and Antonio Gramsci are cited, as well as left-wing leaders in Ecuador such as Arturo Jarrín, Tránsito Amaguaña and Fausto Vargas, among others.

Marxist groups in Ecuador have sought to infiltrate CONAIE (the Confederation of Indigenous Nationalities of Ecuador) since its founding. Some of them were established left-wing parties and movements (Communist Party, Socialist Party, the Maoist Marxist-Leninist Communist Party), but also groups of rebels, such as Alfaro Vive, Montoneros Patria Libre, the “Gías”, Sol Rojo, the FARC and the ELN of Colombia, among others. His cousin Leonidas Iza Quinatoa, when he was president of CONAIE, had contacts with the FARC (https://www.codigovidrio.com/code/la-conexion-ecuador-bolivia/)

CONAIE has participated in various coup attempts, in some cases successful:

- Overthrow of Jamil Mahuad in January 2000; a “National Salvation Board” claimed power for a few hours, led by Army Colonel Lucio Gutiérrez, and also made up of Antonio Vargas – then president of CONAIE – and Carlos Solorzano, the former president of the Supreme Court of Justice.

- In 2005, they participated in the overthrow of their former ally, Lucio Gutiérrez.

- In October 2019, they tried to overthrow President Lenin Moreno (elected by Rafael Correa's Alianza PAIS movement, although Moreno later distanced himself from Correa and his vice president Jorge Glas, due to various corruption convictions).

- In June 2022, CONAIE led a violent strike for 18 days, which included an attempt to impeach President Guillermo Lasso led by the Correismo caucus in the Assembly. After demanding an increase in the subsidy for extra gasoline, ecopaís and diesel, they finally signed an "Agreement" with the Government.

- They had a less leading role in the overthrow of Abdalá Bucaram in 1997, which was led by the Quito middle class.

Interestingly, against Rafael Correa, who imprisoned multiple indigenous leaders and even seized CONAIE's headquarters, there was no similar indigenous strike.

It is difficult to think that a significant percentage of the “bases” of CONAIE, FENOCIN and FEINE (the three organizations that led the strike, the latter of “indigenous evangelicals”) were in agreement with this marginal Marxist tendency; but in any case Iza was elected president of CONAIE by a wide margin.

Now Iza has given a truce of 90 days, but without a doubt he will continue promoting "the tendencies of the revolutionary struggle in Ecuador", as he affirms in his book.


(*) A Spanish version of this column was published in Diario "El Universo" on July 15, 2022.

https://www.eluniverso.com/opinion/columnistas/comunismo-indoamericano-es-barbarie-nota/




Comunismo indoamericano es barbarie

 Por Luis Fierro Carrión (*)

Twitter: @Luis_Fierro_C

El presidente de la CONAIE, Leonidas Iza, y sus coautores (Andrés Madrid, Secretario de la Casa de la Cultura; y Andrés Tapia, dirigente de comunicación de la CONFENIAE), concluyen su libro “Estallido” con la frase “ La luz al final del túnel proviene de la afirmación creída, buscada e impostergable: Comunismo indoamericano o barbarie”.

Los tres, junto al padre de Andrés Madrid, Dimitri Madrid (Decano de la Facultad de Comunicación Social de la Universidad Central del Ecuador) han sido los líderes visibles del movimiento mariateguista en el Ecuador.

Dicho movimiento toma su nombre del marxista peruano José Carlos Mariátegui, quien fundó el Partido Socialista Peruano en 1928, el cual, tras su muerte en 1930, pasaría a denominarse Partido Comunista Peruano, alineado con el estalinismo y la Comintern.

No obstante, Mariátegui era un filosofo marxista original, al realzar el papel de las masas indígenas como el auténtico “proletariado” del continente y pregonar la necesidad de una revolución socialista. De alguna manera, se adelantó al maoísmo, corriente marxista que también dio un papel importante al campesinado (a partir de la invasión japonesa a China, Mao lanzó el “Movimiento de Rectificación de Yan'an” en 1942, que llevó a cabo la principal desviación respecto a la línea soviética, remarcando la importancia del campesinado como sujeto revolucionario).

Otros líderes marxistas que continuaron en esta línea fueron Pol Pot en Camboya, y Abimael Guzmán, líder de Sendero Luminoso en el Perú (el mismo nombre de su grupo terrorista se deriva de una frase de Mariátegui: “el marxismo-leninismo es el sendero luminoso del futuro”).

En el libro “Estallido” se citan a pensadores marxistas como Lenin, Rosa Luxemburgo y Antonio Gramsci, y también a dirigentes de izquierda en el Ecuador como Arturo Jarrín, Tránsito Amaguaña, Fausto Vargas, entre otros.

Grupos marxistas en el Ecuador han buscado infiltrar la CONAIE (la Confederación de Nacionalidades Indígenas del Ecuador), desde su fundación. Algunos de ellos eran partidos y movimientos de izquierda constituidos (Partido Comunista, Partido Socialista, PCMLE-MPD), pero también grupos de alzados en armas, tales como Alfaro Vive, Montoneros Patria Libre, los “Gías”, Sol Rojo, las FARC y el ELN de Colombia, entre otros. Su primo Leonidas Iza Quinatoa, cuando fue presidente de la CONAIE, tuvo contactos con las FARC (https://www.codigovidrio.com/code/la-conexion-ecuador-bolivia/)

La CONAIE ha participado en varios intentos de golpe de Estado, en algunos casos exitosos:

-    -  Derrocamiento de Jamil Mahuad en enero 2000; una “Junta de Salvación Nacional” reclamó el poder durante unas horas, dirigida por el coronel de ejército Lucio Gutiérrez, y conformada también por Antonio Vargas –entonces presidente de la CONAIE– y Carlos Solorzano, el expresidente de la Corte Suprema de Justicia.

-     -   En 2005, participaron en el derrocamiento de su anterior aliado, Lucio Gutiérrez.

-     -   En octubre 2019, intentaron derrocar al presidente Lenin Moreno (electo por el movimiento Alianza PAIS de Rafael Correa, aunque luego se distanció de Correa y su vicepresidente Jorge Glas, por las diversas condenas sentenciadas de corrupción).

-     -   En junio 2022, mantuvieron un paro violento durante 18 días, que derivó en un intento de destitución del presidente Guillermo Lasso encabezado por la bancada del correísmo en la Asamblea. Tras exigir un aumento del subsidio a la gasolina extra, ecopaís y el diésel, finalmente firmaron un “Acuerdo” con el Gobierno.

-     -  Tuvieron un papel menos protagónico en el derrocamiento de Abdalá Bucaram en 1997, que fue encabezado por la clase media quiteña.

Curiosamente, contra Rafael Correa, quien encarceló a múltiples líderes indígenas e incluso le quitó la sede a la CONAIE, no hubo un paro indígena similar.

Es difícil pensar que un porcentaje significativo de las “bases” de la CONAIE, FENOCIN y FEINE (las tres organizaciones que protagonizaron el paro, esta última de “indígenas evangélicos”) estuviesen de acuerdo con una tendencia marxista marginal; pero de cualquier manera Iza fue electo presidente de la CONAIE por un amplio margen.

Ahora Iza ha dado una tregua de 90 días, pero sin duda seguirá propulsando “las tendencias de la lucha revolucionaria en el Ecuador”, como afirma en su libro.

(*) Versión más extensa de mi columna publicada en el Diario "El Universo" el 15 de Julio, 2022.

https://www.eluniverso.com/opinion/columnistas/comunismo-indoamericano-es-barbarie-nota/





Monday, April 5, 2021

Forbidden to Forget

By Luis Fierro Carrión (*)

Twitter: @Luis_Fierro_Eco

Former President Rafael Correa made popular the phrase "Forbidden to forget" on his Saturday public events ("sabatinas"), events which he dedicated to insult his opponents; he even sought to register the phrase as a trademark.

Internet users reminded him that Rubén Blades titled one of his songs "Prohibido Olvidar", which appeared on his album Caminando (1991), which includes among its lines: "Forbidden the free press and forbidden to express opinions... They forbade to go out to the street and criticize the state. They forbade to laugh at the joke of their sad government... I believe the only way to put an end to this is: Forbidden to forget!".

Well, in the weeks before the second round of the elections, it seems that many Ecuadorians have forgotten what happened during the decade of the Correa regime (2007-2017).

For example, Yaku Pérez and Pachakutik seem to have forgotten the persecution they suffered at the hands of the Correista regime, which included the murder of several indigenous leaders (Bosco Wisuma, Freddy Taish, José Tendentza); the blows received by Yaku himself, his partner Manuela Picq, the elected assemblyman Salvador Quishpe, and other leaders of Conaie and Pachakutik. They also seem to forget that the government took the headquarter building away from Conaie (in 2014), which was later restored to them by Lenín Moreno.

Pachakutik and Unidad Popular (MPD) seem to forget that during the Correa decade more than 800 social leaders were arrested, criminalizing social protest; This included cases such as 10 from Luluncoto, 12 from Central Técnico, 21 from Arbolito, etc. Karla Calapaqui documents in her book "Criminalization of the Protest: 2007-2015, the victims of correísmo", the arrests, beatings, torture and murders due to the repression of the social protests.

UP leaders have forgotten that Correa dissolved the National Union of Educators (UNE) in 2016, liquidated its assets and appropriated the retirement fund of the Ecuadorian teachers, the financial entity of the UNE, that held 405 million dollars.

These organizations forget that Correísmo created parallel organizations to divide the social movement, such as the Central Unitaria de Trabajadores (CUT), the Red de Maestros, promoted the Fenocin to counter Conaie, etc.

Have the Yasunidos forgotten how the regime ignored the signatures collected to demand a popular referendum, and proceeded to disrupt the Yasuní protection initiative to begin oil extraction?

Does society forget that there are 35 unsolved murders, which include 15 journalists and people who denounced corruption, such as General Jorge Gabela, Quinto Pazmiño and his wife, the journalist Fausto Valdivieso, among others?

Voters forget that there are reports of acts of corruption estimated by the late president of the National Anticorruption Commission, Jorge Rodríguez, to be at least $ 35 billion, in bribes, overpricing in public contracts, tax evasion, oil export commissions and in importation of derivatives, public debt and current spending. Other estimates calculate losses to the State between 30 and 70 billion dollars; that is between 10 and 20% of fiscal revenue during the 10 years.

We cannot forget that the former president, former vice president Glas, 10 former ministers, 4 assembly members, and directors of the IESS, Petroecuador, the Intelligence Secretariat, and the legal secretary of the Presidency have been indicted and found guilty of corruption.

When the Yasunidos activist, Antonella Calle, asked Arauz "I hope they don't continue to persecute us like in the Correa government", Arauz replied "I hope not." As if he had to consult his mentor if he would allow him to stop repressing. As a result of this exchange, Calle received thousands of insults and threats, in response to which she said “we must appeal to the public memory. They are announcing with great fanfare that the state of terror that Correísmo generated will continue. "

In an interview with Ecuavisa, Arauz said that he aspired for the Correísmo government to extend from 20 to 50 years. This would leave Hervas, Yaku Pérez or any other candidate out of aspiring to replace him.

Hopefully the public memory will awaken.


(*) Translation of the column published in Diario "El Universo" on April 2, 2021.

https://www.eluniverso.com/opinion/columnistas/prohibido-olvidar-nota/